Blog Layout

Checks and Balances

May 24, 2022

Checks and Balances

Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy’s retirement, which was officially announce June 27, 2018 and set to take effect July 31, 2018, gives President Trump a rare opportunity to shift the political alignment of our nation’s highest court.Justice Kennedy has long been the swing vote of the Supreme Court, which is otherwise relatively polarized between four conservatives and four liberals.Although Justice Kennedy was himself considered a conservative, his tendency to vote with liberals on many controversial issues such as abortion and gay marriage, often made him the deciding vote.His retirement gives President Trump the opportunity to replace Justice Kennedy with someone who can be relied upon to vote conservative, which was not always certain with Justice Kennedy.Any such nomination by President Trump will, however, be subject to the system of checks and balances prescribed by the United States Constitution.



While the nomination of Justice Kennedy’s successor will be up to President Trump alone, the nominee will have to be confirmed by a Senate majority vote. Currently, Republicans holds the Senate Majority by the slim margin of 51 out of 100 votes.The midterm elections coming in November could result in a change in that majority, giving Democrats the ability to block President Trump’s nominations, and thereby giving Democrats more leverage to demand someone more moderate replace Justice Kennedy.Considering this, along with the level of recent political divide, it makes sense that the Republicans want to move fast to confirm a nomination before the midterm elections, while Democrats want to wait until after the midterm elections in the hopes that they will take enough Senate seats to claim the majority and oppose any of President Trump’s nominations. Thus, by leveraging the system of checks and balances, whoever controls congress when the nomination is presented will ultimately possess the means to influence the selection of Justice Kennedy’s replacement, despite that selection being up to the President.


While there is no predicting exactly how power will be redistributed following Justice Kennedy’s replacement and the upcoming midterm elections, this situation does provide a good example of how the system of checks and balances, which was designed by America’s forefathers to prevent too much power from being distributed to any particular group or branch of government to ensure tyranny does not replace democracy, does just that by giving each branch of government the means to limit the conduct of the others.With the United States’ 242nd Independence Day approaching, it is especially appropriate to take a moment to remind ourselves why such checks and balances were implemented to begin with and why they remain important today.

immigration law
05 Mar, 2024
New Fee Schedule Will Take Effect on April 1, 2024 
22 Jan, 2024
The Board of Directors of Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison ("GKH"), a Chattanooga law firm, are pleased to announce the election of Kane Shepherd as Director at the firm. Kane guides clients in all aspects of real estate matters, financial and lending transactions, and mergers & acquisitions. Kane represents clients ranging from startups to businesses with large international footprints. Kane is a native of Montana who joined the firm in 2019. He received his undergraduate degree from the University of Montana, and received his J.D. with a concentration in business transactions from the University of Tennessee in 2018. Prior to joining GKH, Kane clerked at the Hamilton County Chancery Court for the Honorable Pamela A. Fleenor and the Honorable Jeffrey M. Atherton, and previously worked as a wildland firefighter for the U.S. Forest Service. To learn more about Mr. Shepherd, please visit his webpage at http://www.gkhpc.com . Contact him at 423-756-8400 or by email at kshepherd@gkhpc.com .
22 Jan, 2024
Five Things to Never Assume About Artificial Intelligence
22 Aug, 2023
David Higney Recognized By Best Lawyers in America for Environmental Law and Energy Regulatory Law
14 Feb, 2023
Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison is please to announce the election of Ms. Sawhill as a Director at the Firm
By Sandy Vander Griend 14 Feb, 2023
Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison is pleased to announce the election of Ms. Lentz as a Director at the Firm
By Sandy Vander Griend 14 Feb, 2023
Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison is pleased to announce the election of Ms. Floberg as a Director at the Firm
By Sandy Vander Griend 14 Feb, 2023
CBA members voted in by acclamation Katherine Lentz, Keith Grant, and Logan Threadgill
07 Dec, 2022
Congratulations to Brittany T. Faith on her recognition as a Volunteer 40 Under 40 recognizes forty alumni under the age of 40 who have excelled personally and professionally since completing their degree at UT Knoxville. Brittany Faith is a nationally recognized immigration attorney who has committed herself to service. At UT’s College of Law she was heavily involved in community service and leadership roles, including serving as director of UT Law’s Pro Bono program; treasurer of Law Women, American Bar Association (ABA) representative for the Student Bar Association; American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) Midsouth law school liaison, and creator/founder of UT Law’s U Visa Alternative Spring Break. Faith currently serves as the Tennessee Bar Association Young Lawyers Division president, one of only 21 elected directors across the country to the AILA Board of Governors, and the Fit2Practice director for the ABA Young Lawyers Division Council. In addition, she regularly donates her time to pro bono and low bono immigration work, which is an area of law with a lack of resources due to federal funding limitations.
More Posts
Share by: